Think Suburbs Are Safer for eBikes? Think Again
Electric bikes (eBikes) are transforming transportation in cities and suburbs alike. But while ridership is growing everywhere, not all environments pose the same level of risk. Research shows a clear divide: suburban eBike riders face higher accident risks than those in urban areas.
The Safety Divide: Urban vs. Suburban
Multiple studies confirm that suburban and township roads carry greater risks of eBike-related traffic injuries compared to urban roads.
-
A case-control study found that suburban and township roads were significantly more likely to result in eBike traffic injuries (ERTIs) than urban areas. Contributing factors include poor road design, rugged surfaces, and less consistent traffic management.
-
In contrast, urban environments—despite higher traffic density—offer safer conditions due to better infrastructure, stricter enforcement, and more widespread safety measures.
Another analysis of eBike–motor vehicle collisions revealed that accidents outside of urban centers tend to cause more severe injuries or fatalities, underscoring the disproportionate risks suburban riders face.
Key Risk Factors by Area
| Area Type | Road Conditions | Traffic Management | Injury Risk |
|---|---|---|---|
| Urban | Developed infrastructure | Higher enforcement | Lower |
| Suburban | Rugged, less developed | Lower enforcement | Higher |
Why suburban roads are riskier:
-
Poor infrastructure: Fewer dedicated bike lanes, inconsistent road quality.
-
Higher vehicle speeds: Suburban roads often allow cars to travel at 45–55 mph, creating deadlier collisions.
-
Weaker enforcement: Less oversight and fewer safety interventions compared to urban centers.
Infrastructure: The Critical Safety Differentiator
The presence (or absence) of protected bike lanes is one of the strongest predictors of eBike rider safety.
-
Protected lanes reduce crash risk by over 50% compared to streets without them.
-
Streets with physically separated bike lanes show 90% lower injury risk compared to major roads without cycling infrastructure.
-
Urban congestion naturally slows vehicles, lowering crash severity, while suburban roads allow higher speeds with fewer signals or traffic calming measures.
This explains the paradox: urban riders encounter more accidents overall, but suburban riders face more severe outcomes.
Demographics and Safety Awareness
Studies also suggest suburban riders often have:
-
Lower helmet usage rates compared to urban riders.
-
Less access to cycling education and awareness campaigns.
-
Populations that may rely more on eBikes for work (e.g., delivery or commuting from areas with fewer transit options), increasing daily exposure to risk.
Urban riders, by contrast, benefit from higher visibility campaigns, community programs, and greater cycling infrastructure investment.
Policy Implications
For suburban areas:
-
Build protected bike lanes on major corridors.
-
Lower speed limits in areas with high eBike use.
-
Improve lighting and visibility on secondary roads.
-
Expand helmet campaigns and safety education for riders.
For urban areas:
-
Continue to expand and maintain protected bike lane networks.
-
Focus on intersection safety, where many urban accidents occur.
-
Upgrade aging infrastructure to preserve safety gains.
Conclusion
The data is clear: urban environments provide safer conditions for eBike riders than suburban or township areas. While suburban crashes may occur less frequently per square mile, they are more severe and more likely to result in fatalities.
The decisive factor is infrastructure. Cities that invest in protected bike lanes, lower vehicle speeds, and robust cycling networks create safer environments for riders—even in dense traffic. For suburban riders to enjoy similar protection, policymakers must prioritize bike-friendly road design and stricter safety measures.
References
-
Zhong, Z., Lin, Z., Li, L., & Wang, X. (2022). Risk Factors for Road-Traffic Injuries Associated with E-Bike: Case-Control and Case-Crossover Study. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 19. https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph19095186
-
Wang, P., Lin, M., Li, X., Wang, W., & Wei, W. (2022). Analysis of factors affecting riders’ injury severity in E-bike-motor vehicle collision accidents based on CIDAS data. Proceedings of SPIE 12302. https://doi.org/10.1117/12.2645678
-
13-Year Study Finds Protected Bike Lanes Make Roads Safer for Everyone