Comparing Rider Safety: eScooters vs. eBikes vs. Regular Bikes (What t – XNITO

<tc>L</tc>IVRAISON GRATUITE DANS TOUS <tc>L</tc>ES SITES AUX ÉTATS-UNIS, AU CANADA ET AU ROYAUME-UNI
Votre panier

Comparing Rider Safety: eScooters vs. eBikes vs. Regular Bikes (What the Data Actually Says)

 Date: 

  Author: Xnito Team

Key Findings at a Glance

  • Injury growth: e-scooter and e-bike ER visits have soared since 2017; 2022 saw ~56.8k e-scooter and ~23.5k e-bike ER injuries in the U.S., while bicycles accounted for ~403.6k (reflecting much larger exposure).

  • Hospitalization share: ~9–11% e-scooter, ~13% e-bike, ~15% bicycle—differences are modest.

  • Helmet use: lowest on e-scooters (often <35%, single-digits in some European datasets); e-bikes ~40%+; bicycles ~50%+.

  • Head injuries: proportionally higher on e-scooters; e-bike crashes more often involve motor vehicles and internal trauma; bicycles see the largest absolute burden (more riders, more exposure).

  • When & how people crash: night riding and alcohol are over-represented for e-scooters; e-bikes collide with cars more often; bike injuries span falls and vehicle conflicts.

 

 

The Trend Line: Injuries Are Rising Fast for Electric Micromobility

Since 2017, ER-treated injuries from e-scooters and e-bikes have climbed steeply in the U.S., particularly after 2020 as adoption surged. Bicycles still dominate total injuries simply because vastly more trips are taken by pedal bikes, but the rate of increase for e-modes is striking.

 

How Bad Are the Injuries? (Severity & Hospitalization)

Across 2021–2022 ER data, the share admitted to hospital is lowest for e-scooters (~9–11%), then e-bikes (~13%), then bicycles (~15%). That suggests most scooter injuries are treat-and-release (cuts, simple fractures), while e-bike and bicycle crashes tilt slightly more severe—often when cars are involved. Fatal outcomes per ER case are rare across all three, though bicyclists have the highest absolute fatalities in traffic records due to exposure.

 

Helmet Use: The Difference Maker (and Where It’s Missing)

Helmet wearing is consistently lowest on e-scooters, which aligns with higher rates of head/facial trauma in that group. e-bike riders wear helmets more often than scooter riders but less than bicyclists, and their crashes skew toward vehicle conflicts at higher speeds—producing more chest/abdominal injuries than pedal bikes. Bottom line: more helmet use = fewer severe head injuries, regardless of mode.

 

What’s Causing the Crashes?

  • e-Scooters: More night riding, more alcohol involvement, spontaneous short trips (and no helmet on hand). Small wheels and a forward stance mean falls often impact face/head first.

  • e-Bikes: Higher speeds and roadway exposure increase the odds of motor-vehicle involvement and internal injuries.

  • Bicycles: Large, diverse user base; injury patterns span falls and car conflicts.

 

Who’s Safest—and Why It’s Complicated

If you normalize by trip/mile, e-scooters appear riskier (higher ED visits per unit of exposure), largely due to low helmet use, late-night riding, and novice riders. e-bikes sit in the middle on many metrics but show more severe crashes when cars are involved. Bicycles look “safest” in some rate comparisons but carry the largest absolute burden because they dominate total trips. None of these modes is “inherently” dangerous—behavior, environment, and protection drive outcomes.

 

Actionable Safety Upgrades (That Actually Move the Needle)

For Riders

  • Wear a certified helmet every trip; ideally one that meets NTA 8776 certification, which is designed for higher-speed micromobility (up to 28 mph).

  • Slow down & ride sober—especially critical on e-scooters at night.

  • Pick safer routes: protected lanes > mixed traffic.

  • Pre-ride checks: brakes, tires/wheels, and (e-modes) battery status.

For Cities & Operators

  • Protected micromobility lanes and calmer intersections.

  • Helmet access nudges: in-app incentives, rental-kiosk helmets.

  • Policy tweaks: geofencing lower speeds at night, DUI enforcement across all modes.

 

Limits & What to Watch

  • Exposure data gaps: Many datasets lack precise miles/trips, making per-mile risk estimates noisy.

  • Mode misclassification: e-bikes/scooters can be miscoded in ER data.

  • Rapid change: Device tech, rider mix, and city rules are evolving; 2026+ studies may look different.

 

Sources & Further Reading

Latest Articles

← Retour à Nouvelles

Net Orders Checkout

Item Price Qty Total
Subtotal $0.00
Shipping
Total

Shipping Address

Shipping Methods